Harmonica (1974) Poster

(1974)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A universal story told in a real life story in a real place on earth
neopisteme13 February 2005
0. Watchers should not be turned off by the location or culture, the story is universal even though told in such a specific geography.

1. Amateur acting in its most authentic way

2. Human desire so palpable

3. Human exploitation so real that you could see it everywhere and recognize it only if you look around yourself

4. The conclusion, I leave it for the movie goers to get to that part but briefly said, a great concluding story.

I could not give it anything less than 10 as I would do it to the other movie of the same director, The Runner. These two are amongst the best movies I have ever seen and I have seen a lot from around the globe.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The golden harmonica.
morrison-dylan-fan28 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Nearing the end in taking part in a poll for the best films of 1974,I started digging for more obscure hidden gems. Curious about the cinema of Iran from that year,I did a search and was delighted to find a title with English Subtitles,leading to me picking up the harmonica.

View on the film:

Placing the camera at the height of the children, writer/director Amir Naderi & cinematographer Ali Reza Zarrindast play a incredibly intimate, documentary-inspired atmosphere from the camera being kept at the height of the children, who see the adults looking disapprovingly down at them, and the child who has gained power from a harmonica being in his hands, towering above them and forcing all to fellow his demands, even sticking a head through (personal prison) bars in a window, just for a moments play.

Filmed on the southern coast of Iran, Naderi goes up the beach with fluid Iran New Wave (INW) panning shots from above, looking down at the dots of children in the middle of a bustling market, where the sound of a harmonica rings out between the background noise.

Crashing the waves of childhood innocence being lost, Naderi jump-cuts to the aggressive faces of the children shoving the others to gain the harmonica, until Naderi breaks the fighting up with a poetic, over saturated INW freeze frame final.

Bringing the harmonica into town via a outsider, the screenplay by Naderi thoughtfully touches on the use of power to keep the population under the bidding of a person, with the mother of the most severely bullied boy telling her son that she does not want to see him "Oppressed", leading to him kicking back from those who view him as their faithful stupid "Donkey",and drowning the power which has been held over him,which finally allows him to play his own tune.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The next future
luismcdbrito22 October 2023
A classic film from Iran on a time were the clash of all cultures in the world was felt in that area of the globe. In the middle of that cultural clash a film that is not about politics, culture or nothing controversial and different to digest. Its about all of us. The pressure and the values that the grown ups pass to the next generation and the next near future.

Wille growning up kids pass through a season were they are mean, in this film this is very clear shown masked by childhood innocence. Curiously in this fase grown ups behave similar, just like their fathers. So its normal. And the future is shaped like normal again and again. To same as before.

The film that we all need to know and understand it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed