"Maigret" Maigret et le fantôme (TV Episode 1993) Poster

(TV Series)

(1993)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Maigret Finn-ishes Off?
Tony-Holmes11 May 2023
Saw this on the Talking Pictures channel, UK older films and TV. They showed the entire collection of the Rupert Davies Maigret episodes (BBC, early 60s) and are now showing this quirky, slow-paced French one (90s) with subtitles.

The atmosphere is very French, lots of slow thoughtful looks, and Maigret wastes few words, which fits with the books, as does the actor's rather lumbering figure.

No real complaints re the lead portrayal, except that in the books he does crack the odd joke, and has some repartee with faithful R-H man Lucas. In this however, Lucas hardly ever appears, not even mentioned in most episodes, which is STRANGE - I cannot recall a book without him featuring in some way!

This particular episode is also most unusual, we hear that Insp Lognon, not that well liked by colleagues, has been shot, but in Helsinki? Nobody knows what he's doing there, Mme Lognon doesn't know, but guesses he was trying to solve a case without Maigret interfering to take the credit?!

Here I could add that I don't recall any Maigret book with Finland in the plot, but I haven't quite read them all. The other TV series seen in the UK, with Rupert Davies, Michael Gambon, and latterly Rowan Atkinson in the lead role, never did this story.

The plot has Maigret in Helsinki, with a Finnish detective to assist and translate (lucky they had one speaking fluent French?!). He soon discovers that Lognon had been in the company of a French prostitute - who has disappeared. But they weren't sleeping together, according to forensics. Attention soon focuses on a Swedish art dealer, though he's at home in many countries (& also speaks good French - what luck!) and it emerges from a witness that Lognon had been watching him, and his French wife, played by the delicious (well, she was in the early 90s!) Elizabeth Bourgine, familiar to British viewers after 10 years in the Death in Paradise crime series.

Maigret's questions get some evasive answers from the couple, and a call back to Janvier in the office reveals that Lognon and the prostitute have some history. She had been in Nice, and so it seems had been the couple, where they married.

The wife has a lover, who could he be? And Maigret starts taking more interest in the dealer's extensive - and very expensive - collection of pictures.

The prostitute is found, she's now running away from the couple, who'd hired her to keep a Russian artist 'company'. What might he have been up to in the attic?

The criminals are safely bagged, including one who is wanted in several countries. The prostitute can go back to France (she'd been deported) after Maigret had rewarded her info with that deal. And Lognon may well return (when recovered) a hero at last, for breaking open a big case (albeit he spent the whole episode in a coma)!

Helsinki looks great, and this episode doesn't need location shooting in a rather grubby Prague, which doubles for Paris in the other episodes.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"But I prefer the original."
garywhalen4 September 2023
The Bruno Cremer "Maigret" series is exceptional and reminds me of those great British books-to-television mystery series from the 80s/90s such as Jeremy Brett's Sherlock Holmes, David Suchet's Hercule Poirot, and (my favorite) John Thaw's Inspector Morse. Having said that, I find this episode, based on "Maigret and the Apparition," a bit weak when compared to the others in the series. While the film (sort of) remains true to the book's core plot-the mystery and motivations-it deviates often from the source material in many ways. Maybe the producers felt a need to take a break from the same locations for shooting and opted to have the story rewritten by setting it in Helsinki (and thus they get a trip to Finland). This change is an awkward one with Maigret directing a case outside of France, and while they do provide a reasonable workaround for that in the script, it still doesn't ring true fully. (I say this but must admit that George Simenon, author of the Maigret books, would occasionally take Maigret out of Paris and even outside of France.) Some book characters are consolidated, and some are changed (e.g., the film has an important character as a prostitute who in the book is not). Also, plot points here and there are different when comparing book to film.

So, what to make of this awkward book-to-film adaptation? How does the film hold up if one doesn't consider the source material or if one hasn't read the source material? I think it's OK, not bad, and worth your time if you like an interesting mystery with a twist or two. Heinz Bennent, as art dealer Gustav Jonker, is perfectly cast and captures the character perfectly. (I'd read the book long before seeing this episode and I found Mr. Bennent to be exactly how I imagined the character.) Elizabeth Bourgine, as his wife Mirella Jonker, pulls off a rather difficult role. Without these two actors I'm not sure I could recommend this episode, but I do because they both are that good.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
More engrossing than most
bob99820 June 2014
This Maigret episode is set in Finland and deals with art forgery and other forms of cheating. Heinz Bennent, whom we remember from Le Dernier metro (he played Deneuve's husband forced to hide from the Nazis) is effective as a shady gallery owner and dealer. His wife is cheating on him with a thug who's good with guns. Maigret is in Helsinki to investigate the shooting of his colleague Lognon, and stumbles upon the shady art dealings by accident.

Bruno Cremer is often outshone by the guest actors, this is no exception. Besides Bennent, there is Elizabeth Bourgine who plays his wife; she's very demure as she hides her past from the authorities.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed