Secrets of a French Nurse (1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
A very old school french crime flick.
searchanddestroy-131 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Adapted from a Jeam Amila's novel, I think it is faithful to the original story. That was not so difficult, very easy to shoot from the book. As far as I remember, the editing of the tale is very similar.

A gangster is back in business after a while and tries to take it back. In the hard way. But every thing goes wrong for him. In the same time, we watch the fate of a young nurse in a hospital. Soon, the two stories meet,when the gangster faces his "problems".

It's a very old fashioned story, as we saw in the fifties, with dialogues that could not be used today. But the characters are fine, especially the mob moll - played by Madeleine Robinson. A hard boiled gangster's wife. Bernard Blier plays the hood in question, sometimes shown as a nasty macho, but on the other hand somewhat sensitive different. With the young nurse.

We can watch this little programmer with pleasure. No length. And, again, surprising characters we don't see every where.

Jean Amila was a crime novel writer who made social stories, the first ones, at a time where the only topics were Agatha Christie likes or gangster tales, in slang spoken. This was the fifties fashion. That movie is built this way. No real social problems are shown here, except perhaps daily life in a hospital.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A hospital you would not like to be taken to.
dbdumonteil28 February 2011
This movie reportedly got into trouble when it was theatrically released :it did contain a certain unfriendly look at the hospitals and their staff.The surgeons smoke here ,there and everywhere -it was probably allowed at the time -,one of them sleeps with a new nurse (played by Stephane Audran,future actress of Chabrol's best movies:she has no line to say),and it's a wonder the patients survive in this place where carelessness reigns.

"LA Bonne Tisane" features two apparently independent plots -unless a short scene in a tobacco shop counts-: -one of them involves a routine gangsters tale we have seen a thousand times or more and it takes all the talent of the actors to make it work all the same :Bernard Blier as a Gabinesque gang leader who makes his comeback ,Madeleine Robinson as his moll (speaking to the dancers/singers of her nightclub,Robinson delivers the best line of the movie : "people don't care about your singing,they wanna see you stark naked!")and Carné's friend, Roland Lesaffre, as their chauffeur.

-the second plot is much less derivative for it tells the first night of a new nurse.An idealist ,she's horrified by the way her colleagues and the doctors behave ,scandalized by their cynicism.If the medical profession was angry with the movie,there was REALLY something to complain about!The young virtuous nurse (played by absolutely gorgeous Estella Blain whose fate was tragic:she committed suicide in the early eighties after the failure of her career)will spend a "night to remember" ....

....for the two plots meet,halfway through,when Blier is seriously injured and taken to the hospital,as it may have been expected .Half farce ,half film noir,the last part loses steam in the final sequences but yet features an incredible scene where all the patients watch the cops/robbers settlement of scores from the windows of their hospital.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed