The Silent Code (1935) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Wait six months and they'll forget they saw it in April.
horn-511 December 2005
Writer George Morgan has a "Original Story and Screenplay" credit---written just like that---and while there is no doubt he did write the screenplay for "The Silent Code," he may have been fibbing a bit when it came to the Original Story credit.

Back in April of 1935, Columbia Pictures Corporation released a film with Tim McCoy,as a Canadian Mountie, called "Fighting Shadows." And, in September, Louis Weiss's International Pictures Inc. production company, (which is not the same company as the International Pictures Inc. company of the mid-1940's that later merged with Universal Pictures Corporation to form the Universal-International production company )produced and distributed, via the Weiss-owned "Stage and Screen Productions Inc. distribution company, "The Silent Code." Of course, there were a lot of USA-produced films featuring the Royal Canadian Mounted Police made in the 1930's---only a few of which were actually filmed in Canada and only then to comply with the British Import Law---so it is no coincidence that the 1935 version of International Pictures Inc. would make a Canadian Mounted film within a few short months of one made and distributed by Columbia Pictures Corporation. But...it do strain credibility a bit when both films have exactly the same plot, beginning with a Mountie being reassigned to a district he had been run out of earlier and not missing a beat from there. The only difference is in the cast/crew credits, plus Morgan gave this film's hero a dog named Rex (played by a dog named Wolfang)and Tim McCoy only had a horse to talk to in the Columbia film.

Of course it doesn't matter...but since both films are readily available for viewing, those who collect films of this era might enjoy watching these two back-to-back just to see how a real Poverty-Row company fared when they did an unauthorized/uncredited remake of a borderline Poverty Row company film...on about one-third less budget.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Bring on the Mounties!
JohnHowardReid3 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
My previous reviewer has written a fascinating account of this film's remarkable similarity to a previous version. I have not seen the previous version so cannot comment on that aspect, but I did find the plot somewhat hazy and even a little difficult to follow. Not that it matters all that very much because the movie has some really good production values and it is most certainly admirably fast moving.

Even more importantly, we viewers are treated to plenty of action, involving some very interesting characters, played to perfection by people like Kane Richmond, J.P. McGowan and most particularly, Blanche Mehaffey.

Stuart Paton directs with his usual adroit competence, and the movie is certainly admirably fast-moving. Indeed some viewers (like me, for instance) may find that it moves just a little too fast for a really total comprehension, although the players do try to fill in some of the gaps and other details from time to time when they are not too busy chasing, fighting and out-smarting!

I also think 7 is too low a value. I would definitely give this movie a 7.5 rating.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed