User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Cinematography Rather Than Story
Theo Robertson8 October 2005
Interesting to note that the previous commentator was confused why any of the characters needed to be French . Here's me screaming " Duh it's because it's a French short film Bob " until I checked after seeing it and was amazed to find out that it's a British made short film which leads me to ask why it was filmed in French . Maybe it has a " French " sense of humour ?

Regardless of its country of origin I wasn't too taken with it . Like a great number of short films with a running time of shorter than three minutes it's more of a sketch than anything else and certainly one that won't have too many people falling about in the aisles , I guess that's why I thought it was a French production - I didn't quite get the humour , and I suppose the idea behind it was so director Richard Clark could dazzle the audience with some clever cinematography
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Rather sick and rather goofy!
planktonrules5 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very short film that made me laugh--especially towards the very end when it got even weirder! The film consists of a French couple having dinner and talking about a lot of unimportant chit-chat. You see the world from the man's perspective. However, when eating pasta, it flies up and hits him in the face and gets all over his glass eye. Not particularly caring about shocking people, he pops the eye out and begins to clean it--at which point his wife justifiably insists he excuse himself to the restroom to fix it.

There's more to the story than this and there are a few cute twists and turns. However, the biggest star of this film is the goofy camera work and clever idea that make it well worth seeing.

By the way, while I really liked the short, I really disliked the subtitles. Often the person doing them only captioned some of the dialog and this annoyed me. While it helped that I could understand much of what wasn't being translated, some viewers might not. Still, it doesn't seriously harm the film--it's just a minor annoyance.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Well directed but quite shallow and pointless
bob the moo26 October 2002
A man and a woman sit having dinner. We witness this from the man's POV. However the man is a messy eater of the pasta and gets some on his eye. When he starts to clean it, it falls out and rolls along the floor sparking a chase around the restaurant, much to the woman's embarrassment.

Made with Hide and Fuel for FilmFour this short continues their trend of being disposable and slightly amusing. The idea here is that we see through a glass eye which then takes a roll. `What's the point?' I hear you ask - well me too. The point seems to be to have a film that shows off the ability of the camera crew, and in fairness it does that very well. The shots are clever and well filmed.

However it's all too light and not funny enough to sustain even a 3 minute running time. It's a little gross but the joke is done early on and there is no build to a punchline that was needed for a good finish. The cast don't do well - they only play strange French caricatures rather than characters, and I don't understand why they needed to be French anyway!

Overall if you can watch all three shorts at once then they probably make for an amusing 10 minutes. One for one they are disposable at best and just about worth watching once. When I saw them they all reminded me of a quick fire sketch show like The Fast Show or something. However these `sketches' are not funny enough or clever enough generally to make it onto a show like that.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed