The Marble Heart (1913) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Three Thanhouser Stars
Cineanalyst9 January 2010
Thanks to the efforts of a non-profit preservation organization, the films of the Thanhouser Company have been well represented on home video relative to the releases of other silent era production studios. This film, "The Marble Heart", features three of the company's most prolific stars: Marguerite Snow, Florence La Badie and would-be director James Cruze. La Badie doesn't have a part of much interest in this adaptation, although they could've further developed the love triangle to make her part more interesting; yet, the other two have rather significant roles for the two-reeler. Cruze plays a sculptor who's in love with his model played by Snow, but she doesn't reciprocate this love—she has a "marble heart" and seems only interested in wealth. It's slightly interesting to see three of the studio's talents together for one production, but the film is mostly a throwaway melodrama ripe for some overacting. And, it's made poorly, using a style where title cards tell us what happens before we see it. That was becoming dated even by 1913. It also would've been better if the film did more with its subject of art by becoming a piece of art itself.

There's an odd dream sequence where the sculptor imagines himself in Ancient Rome, with a story that's analogous to the outer narrative. Additionally, in the dream, the sculpture briefly takes on lifelike movement.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It has, altogether, considerable appeal
deickemeyer4 September 2017
This two-reel offering tells a story of a sculptor who loved the woman who posed for his masterpiece. The opening part is given a modem setting, with James Cruze as the sculptor, Raphael. Flo La Badie appearing as a homeless girl he has befriended, loves him devotedly, but he cares only for the model, played by Marguerite Snow. He has a dream, in which he sees himself and all the other characters in a previous incarnation, the scenes being laid in Rome. Through this dream he finally understands that his model has a marble heart. This so affects him that he smashes his statue of her and dies brokenhearted. This is well played, the costumes are attractive and it has, altogether, considerable appeal. - The Moving Picture World, May 24, 1913
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed