User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
You will hate Marty Feldman from here on..
westernone8 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
BBC's "Wednesday Play" series will always be one of the most harrowing experiences television offered in the twentieth century. This presentation is no exception.

Marty Feldman was always billed as a comedian, though I always felt the only bit of talent he had was his distictively creepy, insect-eyed appearance. Here he excersises his darker side, by playing an insane sadist, mounting a frightening verbal assault, then a deadly threat with a gun, on a helpless, innocent stranger he's locked into railway coach with. He spews angry rubbish about what a righteous victim of class inequality as he tortures his apparently decently middle class prey.

In the second section he breaks into a home a poor scared woman who's mentally imballanced herself. The tables are turned around in time when they both find they have been in mad houses at one time, and she tries scaring and controlling him.

In a non sequitur ending, he flees the house, and meets his double or twin in the back of an auto with two total strangers in it. If you're contemptuous of your audience enough to force this hour of misery on them, why not have a pointless conclusion. Just so it ends! One is very hard pressed to have a pleasurable go of it with this series, always some heavy-handed liberal effort to make it's suffering audience "think", or something. This might have been their concept of a "comedy". Nasty stuff.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The Entitled Extrovert
midbrowcontrarian4 October 2023
We introverts have all been there. Sitting on a train or in a pub, harmlessly reading a book or newspaper. An extrovert joins us and wastes little time before uttering the dreaded words "is that something interesting you're reading?". One would love to reply that I'm only pretending to read to deter people from talking to me. But no, we give a polite, straightforward answer, letting us in for an interminable period of his (sadly it's always a he) boorish and unwelcome company.

The Compartment takes this quotidian scenario to extremes. Marty Feldman plays Bill, a chippy, manic extrovert who imposes himself on introvert Joby Blanshard in an old style train compartment. It's well acted but I can't rate it any higher because it's very unpleasant viewing, like spending half an hour watching a nasty youth torture a rabbit.

There should have been a sequel where the introvert turns the tables and invites Bill to his house for a drink. After drugging him, he keeps him prisoner, providing food and drink, books, and a newspaper of his choice. But no TV, radio, or any conversation. Forced to live as a reclusive introvert, we could have enjoyed seeing Bill driven even madder than he already was.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed