"Bonanza" Look to the Stars (TV Episode 1962) Poster

(TV Series)

(1962)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Measuring the Speed of Light
bkoganbing17 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
In the entire run of the Bonanza series twice the Cartwright clan ran into true life human beings who when they were running the Ponderosa, who resided in Virginia City. One was an episode about Mark Twain where Howard Duff played the legendary American writer in his early years.

The other was this episode which involved Albert Michaelson the first American to win a Nobel Prize. He was born in Prussia in what is now part of Poland and did in fact come to America with his parents where they were merchants in Virginia City. In 1869 young Michaelson won a presidential appointment to the Naval Academy in Annapolis from President Ulysses S. Grant where he stayed on as an instructor after graduating. It was the start of his career.

This Bonanza episode offers a fictional account of how Michaelson got that appointment. The key figure here is schoolmaster William Schallert who won't recommend him and his recommendation carries a lot of weight. The Cartwrights in this episode force Schallert to confront his own prejudices which include anti-Semitism.

Joe DeSantis and Penny Santon play the older Michaelsons and young Douglas Lambert winningly plays Albert. It was one of Bonanza's best episodes. The only gunfire was that of Hoss firing his pistol in the air so that young Albert could measure the speed of the sound at which it traveled.

What made Bonanza so endearingly popular to the public then and in syndication ever since was the family and the relationships the Cartwright sons had with each other and with their father. Three half brothers and their father facing all kinds of problems every week. We all got to know the Cartwrights, know them better than some of our relatives. And we cared about them.

In this episode the Cartwrights interacted with the Michaelsons to help them realize their own vision of the American dream. Hopefully Bonanza fans and others won't miss this one if it's broadcast again.
24 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Just a slow episode
glitterrose31 December 2021
And I just give it the two stars because at least it's not a storyline about somebody going into heat.

I also want to touch base on another review. That person is saying something that I thought about "Little House on the Prairie". I use Little House because I honestly prefer it over Bonanza if I had to pick one over the other. You had the attitude on that series of being kind to others and the only exception were the "meanie" characters like Harriet, Nellie and Nancy Oleson. I think the Kennedy character was just a difficult man. Judd Larabee was the racist of Walnut Grove. I do realize realistically that you'd definitely have more "Larabees" on Little House and in Bonanza than what's portrayed.

But here's the thing...I'm glad things got cleaned up so these series could stay on the air. Not that I'm a fan of the series, does anybody think "The Dukes of Hazzard" will ever play on tv again? These shows might not be playing anywhere ever again if they truly stuck with how things were back in the day.

Anyway, I will also agree with that reviewer about rolling my eyes about the teacher keeping his job and all the people he was prejudiced again were approving of this.

And I'll also agree with that other review about Dr. Quinn. That reviewer definitely doesn't sound like a fan of that series. I have watched through the entire series and the writers did a poor job of writing for Dr. Quinn and Sully. They were so perfect that they were nauseating. At least I can snark on Charles and Laura when watching Little House. I think the Cartwrights main snark coming out of me is how they're constantly falling in "luv". But overall they're good guys and they're not nauseating to watch.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
every bit as bad as "Dr Quack, Modern Woman"
grizzledgeezer6 June 2013
Inasmuch as Albert Michelson grew up around Virginia City, someone must have thought that getting the Cartwrights involved in his life would make an interesting story. * It might have, but this isn't it.

Given Michelson's great intelligence, the Cartwrights try to get him appointed to the Naval Academy, so he can receive the education he deserves. But... Michelson is thwarted at every turn by his teacher (William Schallert) who doesn't like people with dark skin, or Jews, or fill in the name of any discriminated-against minority.

Of course, justice wins out in the end, and Schallert is even allowed to keep his job after promising to never, ever do bigoted things again. (Spare me.)

AS A LIBERAL, I detest this rewriting of history to "prove" that some people (eg, the Cartwrights) were good and decent and unprejudiced and just and (fill in whatever positive attributes you care to). Such stories are little more than an excuse for the viewer /not/ to feel guilty about their own failings.

"In the real world", the white citizens of Virginia City would have had little social tolerance for people who looked or acted differently. They wouldn't have given a damn whether Michelson was admitted to Annapolis. Indeed, I suspect Michelson was nominated and appointed without any problems.

* Given Michelson's stated age of 16, the story would have had to take place in 1868 or 1869. I couldn't find a chronology for the Ponderosa or the Cartwrights, so I don't know if this is accurate.
5 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed