"Combat!" A Walk with an Eagle (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Arrogance
claudio_carvalho10 April 2018
While returning from a mission with Doc and Privates Harmon and Palmer, Lt. Hanley is assigned to rescue the pilot Major Robert Caldwell from the German lines. Caldwell is an important asset for the Allied forces and soon the squad stumbles upon him. However the man is arrogant and stubborn and decides to rescue his right-hand that has crashed his plane too in a nearby spot. He jeopardizes the squad and Hanley´s mission since his war experience is in the air and not in the field.

"A Walk with an Eagle" is another great episode of "Combat!" but with a storyline of an arrogant officer that has friction with Lt. Hanley which has been used in other episodes. It is also funny how the courier easily finds Lt. Hanley to transmit his next assignment. The conclusion is highly entertaining. My vote is eight.

Title (Brazil): "A Jornada com Uma Águia" ("The Journey with an Eagle")
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The aerial ace
nickenchuggets27 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
In the excellent World World II series World at War, I remember an RAF pilot saying how the war in the air had a certain alternate reality to it. He elaborates by saying a pilot doesn't feel the same sense of loss or shock seeing one of his friends get shot down as an infantryman would if the latter sees someone get his head blown off or something. This episode of Combat shows how those who fought in planes during the war still had a difficult job just like all other servicemen, especially if they were brought down. The episode begins with a P-47 Thunderbolt pilot named Major Caldwell (Lee Philips) and his wingman being shot down by German planes near Hanley's position. He is told by a jeep driver to go rescue Caldwell, as he is something of a war trophy for the Nazis. Having over 20 enemy planes to his credit, the Major is quite the skilled flyer. After Hanley and the others find where Caldwell is and hide his parachute from german patrols, Caldwell tells the squad that his wingman is nearby and must be safely returned to him before the germans find him. They find Caldwell's wingman in an open field laying on the grass, and Hanley suspects a trap. Sure enough, germans ambush the squad when they approach him. The wingman is killed, along with a Private from the squad. Later, the Major is wounded and Doc attempts to get him to safety via a route Hanley thinks is free of german forces, but Caldwell, outranking Hanley, orders him to take a shortcut through a cornfield. Despite Caldwell's certainty, the squad runs into germans. In the ensuing gunfight, another squad member is killed, and Doc is wounded. Hanley and Caldwell work together in order to ambush a german patrolman and steal his motorcycle. Using it, Hanley drives Caldwell to safety while being chased by a second german bike. Caldwell then takes it upon himself to ride back into harm's way in order to save Doc. The two of them make it back to Hanley, who is waiting to ambush the german cycle with his carbine. After the driver and the guy in the sidecar are both dead, Hanley, Doc and Caldwell get into the second motorcycle and ride off. This episode is alright. The beginning kind of irritates me as someone who likes to read about world war 2. Caldwell is (supposedly) a quadruple ace, having over 20 kills to his name, and yet his flight of Thunderbolts gets bounced by a couple of Junkers Ju-87 dive bombers. The Stuka (as it was called) was a poor choice for air to air combat due to its sluggish speed and non-retractable landing wheels, not to mention its anemic armament which didn't include any cannons. Additionally, the P-47 was a notably difficult plane to bring down, the designers at Republic Aviation doing their jobs well when it came to installing armor plates. I found Caldwell to be not that intriguing as a person, since he doesn't really have anything that makes him special besides being a pilot, and therefore unattached to the ground aspect of world war 2. Being another episode in which Morrow doesn't appear, it was nice to have the focus on Hanley once again. Just a shame he technically isn't in charge anymore once he meets Caldwell.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Jason & Philips Show
jmarchese21 August 2014
"A Walk With An Eagle" is a story highlighting the ignorance & arrogance of USAF Major Robert Caldwell (excellently played by Lee Philips) who is completely out of his league on the ground in German territory.

Lieutenant Hanley receives an order to find & rescue Caldwell, a very valuable USAF ace who' s been shot down in the area. Upon rescue Caldwell proves to be a very headstrong individual bent on doing everything his own way even though he knows nothing about ground combat & strategy.

John Peyser directed this fine episode portraying why US Army officers should never be outranked by Navy or Air Force personnel on the ground while in enemy territory. The story is very believable and flows logically. Excellent & abundant conflict is generated between Hanley, the squad, and Caldwell, a testament to fine screen writing by Rod Peterson. In addition, Hanley & Caldwell have an outstanding aside while in deep trouble in which both detail out their job philosophies, infantry versus air.

The ending sequence is hysterically amusing yet very believable considering the dust element and necessity being the mother of creativity.

"A Walk With An Eagle" is loaded with conflict & suspense, fun to watch, and ends with reconciliation and great teamwork between Hanley and Caldwell.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Contrived script and one-dimensional flyboy to hate
lor_18 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Rick is stuck with a tough assignment (with Vic and most of the cast regulars taking the week off): to fetch a downed pilot behind enemy lines. It's Lee Philips, a pain-in-the-neck big shot major who keeps bossing Rick around, pulling rank, and putting the squad in jeopardy.

One-sided script makes the major such an obviously hissable bad guy that there's no real drama here, just tragedy for Rick to deal with. Doc is on hand to take care of the wounded and conveniently none of our dear regulars are around to get killed. Most heavy-handed moment occurs when Philips needs to sacrifice his treasured scarf to enable doc to bind his belly wound.

Will the arrogant officer/pilot learn his lesson? Who cares?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed