"Combat!" Beneath the Ashes (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Two Dramatic and Full of Action Storylines
claudio_carvalho19 April 2018
Saunders and his squad go to a recon patrol in a French village. They surprise a German squad in a building and kills them, but Littlejohn is wounded. When they are ready to return to their base, a German truck arrives in the village and the troop comes to the same building. Saunders and his squad are trapped in the basement and Saunders decide to wait for the German to leave the spot. Meanwhile Lt. Hanley receives a letter to Pvt. Steve Kovac informing that his wife is dying. While the Red Cross checks the information, Hanley withholds the information to spare anxiety to Kovac. Now the squad is missing in action and Hanley does not have means to tell Kovac. When they return, Kovac´s wife is dead and the resentful soldier blames Hanley. On their next assignment, Hanley needs Kovac´s support to save his life. What will Kovac do?

"Beneath the Ashes" is another great episode of "Combat!" with two dramatic and full of action storylines. The attitude of Hanley is correct despite the consequence. The initial attitude of Kovac and his final redemption are also expected. My vote is eight.

Title (Brazil): "Coberto por Cinzas" ("Covered by Ashes")
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Can't Blame Hanley!
ShelbyTMItchell29 November 2013
Warning: Spoilers
You can't blame Hanley for the way that he had to withheld the letter to the Chad Everett character. Which he was on patrol and that the King's Company was short handed.

As Everett's character's wife is sick and is dying. But Hanley needs him to focus on the mission. As Saunders and his men are running into huge trouble. And by releasing the Everett character would mean a long way from emergency leave for him.

As Hanley can't afford to do that. And needs all the men power in the world. And that is the reason he withheld it. But after he tells Everett that his wife passed away awhile back and that Everett accused Hanley of withholding information despite Saunders saying that his LT and friend was only doing his job.

At first Everett thinks Hanley needs to get his just desserts and let him die. As he follows a German patrol to trap Hanley. But Saunders gives Everett his usual pep talk and Everett is really not the caring and honest husband he is.

As Saunders confronts him about it. You will have to watch what I mean and will Everett save Hanley and forgive him in time? You will just have to watch the episode in order to see for himself!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Lieutenants Are Human Too
jmarchese5 September 2014
"Beneath The Ashes" is a story about an unintentional bad decision made by Lieutenant Hanley regarding one of his men and its after effects on that man. Through Private Steve Kovac (well played by Chad Everett) we learn about the defense mechanism "projection" - projecting one's inferior impulses onto others to relieve our own anxiety.

Private Kovac is on patrol with Saunders, Caje, Kirby, & Littlejohn when Lieutenant Hanley receives a letter from Detroit stating his wife is on her deathbed. Instead of calling Kovac back, Hanley figures the squad will return in a few hours and in the meantime the Red Cross can check the letter's validity. Unfortunately the squad is pinned down in a cellar for two days and classified as MIA. Upon the squad's return, Saunders speaks a defining great line. And Radio Operator Mac (played by Noam Pitlik) puts foot in mouth to set the story in motion.

Richard P. McDonagh wrote an adequate story; his idea was to tie in loose ends at the ending which he outstandingly did when The Sarge had it out with Kovac on the battlefield. Great dialog. The cellar scene is a little unrealistic considering lack of facilities and the unlikelihood of Littlejohn's survival. Chad Everett came across adequately, but not in great fashion. Heavy artillery and combat scenes are excellent throughout. The village hand grenade scene with the German coming out of the doorway is priceless - analogous to Otis Campbell heading to jail on the Andy Griffith Show.

All in all "Beneath the Ashes" was entertaining considering a mediocre script and average acting.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fire the writers!
lor_26 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Chad Everett guest stars as a brash soldier out on patrol with Vic and his squad, who's unaware that his wife back home in America is dying in hospital. Rick decides not to give him the bad news until he makes it back from patrol.

For the viewer, it's sort of instant drama: we know the problem facing Chad but he carries on in a carefree manner, in blissful ignorance, while harsh battling with the Germans is ongoing and Littlejohn is seriously wounded and in pain.

Key plot twist is way too contrived to be believable: Chad is understandbly angered when he returns to discover his wife has died and Rick withheld the info, but on the next mission he needs to help save Rick's life. Methinks the "Combat!" Writers Room piled on the melodrama way too much this time.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed