"Fantasy Island" Homecoming/The Sheikh (TV Episode 1978) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
2/10
One of the more ridiculous episodes and that's saying a lot
johnhsmith-0005612 February 2022
This follows the typical Fantasy Island formula of one serious fantasy, one lighthearted one.

The serious one is pretty tragic, and I think most people will be very unsatisfied with the ending. You also have to wonder why Fantasy Island was involved, it could have been handled without Mr. Roarke's intervention.

The light hearted one concerns the fantasy of a man who wants to be a Sheik in charge of his own harem. Notwithstanding that a stereotypical harem as most people think of it didn't really exist, this one looks even more ridiculous than usual, with the most cheap and tacky looking harem outfit costumes imaginable, and all the women are obviously from California, not the Middle East. Sid Haig fans might enjoy his appearance though.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
HATE this episode!
laley-5818222 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
It is unfair to everyone involved to keep on pretending that Sgt. Alan Boardman is dead.....I REALLY did not like this episode!! I wish I could give it 0 stars instead of 1!

I love Fantasy Island but this episode absolutely s*cks!!!!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Egregious
americanbeautyd24 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I just watched this episode, season 2 episode 2, Homecoming, and I'm so upset right now at the message it sent. I am a huge Fantady Island fan, but not a fan of this story. A man fights for our country, is held in a prison camp and burned beyond recognition, and somehow escapes with his life after 8 years. So he wants to see his wife and son again, and Roarke so ehow had the idea that instead of telling his son , who is still grieving his father, that he is actually alive, he should never tell them since his wife is now remarried and apparently the step father lives the son, and not to tell anyone he's alive because it might be a problem in other people's lives... meaning that this poor guy has no family, he'll never see his sons wedding or hold his own grandkids, and all to be brave and just let well enough be lol. So how does he collect his past earnings? He can't tell anyone he's alive? So no friends, no family just start over so his wife diesnt have to deal with reality, and naybe she would have not fallen apart or divorced the guy, but he'd be a father to his son ffs. Omg im so mad right now because this message is so flawed.i know I'm complaining to nobody but I don't care, and the others who took the time to review agree as well. This episode was not ok Mr Roarke lol.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
All kinds of bad
xbatgirl-3002928 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Part of me wanted to skip watching this and I should have gone with my first instinct. Every part of this episode is really terrible.

I will admit part of my problem is that I really never liked Artie Johnson like at all. But I like the rest of the guest cast - and I especially wanted to see Cassandra Peterson pre-Elvira! She looked amazing of course playing a woman in a harem, but I was left wondering if she was embarrassed to be there (I don't blame her due to the horrible script this week). I figure she was just there for the paycheck. In her biggest scene (her part is tiny), she kept her face often turned away from the camera. Even at one point when she was closest to the camera, she pulled her veil over to cover the small part of her face that was showing. She had Groundlings training, but maybe she was so new to tv, she didn't know where face.

Anyway, this is part of the lamer story, which is super problematic by today's standards, where Artie plays a proto-incel surrounded in daily life by women he thinks reject him, so his fantasy is to completely control a group of women, including sexually (just like today). Of course, typical of the day, it's a white man's version of a harem where all parts are played by white people and Arab culture is extremely stereotypical, exoticized, romanticized. It's made even grosser when Georgia Engel turns up (who I always really liked, and she looks amazing here too btw). She announces she's been in love with Johnson's character for years and her only fantasy was of getting him, even though he's a disgusting pig who never noticed her until she was dressed like a belly dancer. His character is so disgusting!

Anyway, there's also a side story where Tattoo is down because of his size. Now, in hindsight, we know Hervé struggled with depression about his size for years and eventually killed himself. Mostly, Mr Roarke is very sweet to him and Hervé gets a chance to act a bit. But also Roarke does tell him to stop feeling sorry for himself and get over it. Not the best approach, looking back.

The last story was 2/3 pretty good, as far fetched tv situations go. There was a red flag when Roarke hinted David Burney's character should keep his identity a secret from his family. But the schmaltzy plot went along as expected for a while and I even teared up at one time. When the son ran away & all, I thought "I get it. I know how this will go. Now he understands how much the stepfather loves the son. He respects his wife's choices. I bet it'll even turn out the wife had figured out who he was by then. There'll will be a kiss and then hugs. And loaded Alan will pay for the kid's school. Hell, maybe the kid can live with him while at school." Happy ending!

Now remember, at this time in 1978, it was new that so many families were getting divorced. Many were freaking out and it was always in the media. Parental rights was a big thing. Also custody of kids was confusing. There were lots of bad choices and decisions. So I figured maybe the writer of the show was going to be making some statement about how divorce and co-parenting works.

Boy was I wrong! Are you kidding? The show's stance is "it's best to go on thinking dad is dead!?!" Just wow. And this is presented as the moral thing to do. Alan needs to just suck it up and let go?!?

What the heck was going on in the writers' room that week? I'm just giving this 2 stars instead of one for Cassandra Peterson, who is an icon.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed