"Gunsmoke" Cholera (TV Episode 1956) Poster

(TV Series)

(1956)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
"If that don't beat a hen a-peckin'"
wdavidreynolds23 December 2021
The McCreadys and the Gabriels are feuding neighbors. Jim and Jenny Gabriel with their son David are homesteaders who have lived on land they claimed a few months earlier. McCready is a wealthy rancher who decided he wants the Gabriels' land since they found a water source on it.

During this story, Matt Dillon, Chester Goode, and Doc Adams will all be drawn into the feud. As is usually the case in such disputes, both parties will suffer unintended tragic consequences based on their actions.

Actress Peg Hillias portrays the strong-willed Jenny Gabriel in this story, which was her only appearance in the Gunsmoke series. Hillias began her career by playing Eunice in A Streetcar Named Desire. She was a highly regarded talent, but she died in 1960 of undisclosed causes.

Paul Fix was a fixture in an enormous number of television dramas and films during his extensive, prolific career. He was perhaps best known for the role of Marshal Micah Torrance in The Rifleman series. Fix appeared in five Gunsmoke episodes, including this one where he plays the villainous rancher McCready.

Bartlett Robinson did not play nearly as many roles as Fix, but he was also a familiar face in television dramas. He appeared in seven different Gunsmoke episodes, all in the half-hour episode seasons. Robinson plays Jim Gabriel in this story.

Stuart Whitman appears only in this single Gunsmoke episode as McCready's hired hand, Bart. Around the time he played this part, he began appearing in the series Highway Patrol as Sergeant Walters. He would star as Marshal Jim Crown in the western series Cimarron Strip in its single season. Later in his career, he played recurring characters in both Knot's Landing and Superboy.

Gordon Gebert plays Billy McCready in his only Gunsmoke involvement. Gebert guest starred in several popular television shows and a handful of films in the 1950s. In his late teens he chose to quit acting and pursue a career in architecture, in which he found success.

Watch for a young John Smith, who plays David Gabriel in this story. While the character is the subject of much discussion, he is only seen briefly in the episode. Smith's birth name was Robert Errol Van Orden, but he changed it at the suggestion of his agent, who also chose the names for Tab Hunter and Rock Hudson. Smith was best known for his starring role as the character Slim Sherman in the series Laramie. The actor was close friends with John Wayne.

The story of a wealthy rancher resentful of homesteaders and trying to drive them off their land is all too familiar in the western genre, but John Meston's story and Les Crutchfield's screenplay adds some unexpected twists along the way that add to the story's intrigue.

(It is worth noting the story never addresses the possible source of the disease being the spring Jim Gabriel discovered. Drinking water or eating food that has been contaminated with human feces that contain the bacteria that causes cholera are the most common ways the disease is spread. Likewise, it would be unusual for people to die from cholera within hours of the symptoms appearing as is depicted in this story.)
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nobody wins in this western feud
kfo94945 June 2013
This story centers around a feud between the McCreadys' and the Gabriels' which involves the powerful McCready family and the homestead of the Gabriel family. McCready is wanting the land that the Gabriels' possess since they have found a natural spring on the land and Mr McCready is set to do anything to get the land.

The feud appears to come to a halt when the Gabriel's young son comes down with symptoms of cholera. But little do we know that the feud is just heating and the ending will not satisfy anyone.

A fairly simple story that ends with a sobering twist. With some fine guest actors and a regal performance by James Arness, this episode proved to be interesting tale. Even with the slow start the ending made the entire episode worthy of watching. Good show.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Develops into Powerful Entry
dougdoepke6 October 2011
The story is slow to develop, but ends powerfully. Rancher McCready (Fix) uses dirty tricks to get homesteaders Gabriel (Robinson) and wife (Hillias) off land he claims as his own. Then the Gabriel boy gets sick and Doc rides out to help, but never arrives. Now Matt's involved.

About two-thirds through, the story gets really unpredictable following an imaginative twist. There's a good reason why that fine actress Peg Hillias (Streetcar Named Desire {1951}) is in the cast. Her plain but strong face is perfect for the pivotal wife's part. The ending is more morally complex than usual, causing me to wonder how things should be sorted out.

Excellent thought-provoking script from writer Crutchfield. Note Doc's rather surprising admission about the state of his profession. Despite being first shown during the holidays of 1956, it's hardly a holiday episode. My only complaint is the close-out music, usually a series strength. Here, the score is triumphal instead of the more appropriately wistful or downbeat. Maybe the producers thought the episode needed a final uplift.

(In passing—- note the presence down the cast list of two later stars of TV and movie westerns, namely, Whitman and Smith. Here they're almost unrecognizable in their brief parts.)
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Prolly shouldn't submit this. Too late.
birdgoog18 September 2020
Dang. Sad story. So ok but check this out ... i've seen this episode multiple times. Today is the FIRST TIME i recognized McCready was "Paul Fix"!! i mean. This is Micah from the Rifleman FFS! lol and from God knows how many John Wayne movies!? PAUL FIX U DUMMY! So in an effort to ignore and divert the blame from myself, i've chosen to believe what i'm about to share with you: Paul Fix is the GREATEST ACTOR WHO EVER LIVED!! THAT is WHY i didn't recognize him when it was soo OBVIOUS! ... it's NOT because i was lazy. Or high. ... it's NOT.
5 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Outbreak
StrictlyConfidential9 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
(*Jim Gabriel quote*) - We've put our blood and sweat into that land."

"Cholera" was first aired on television December 29, 1956.

Anyway - As the story goes - When Doc doesn't turn up to treat a suspected cholera outbreak, Marshal Dillon sets out to find him.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Not very good
LukeCoolHand14 October 2021
I did not find this episode as intriguing as other reviewers did. It was boring and the plot was all over the place. My second viewing of it proved more boring than the first. It may not have been the worst episode of Gunsmoke I've ever seen but I'm sure it is in the bottom 10.
1 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Matt Dillon Corrupt!!!
omnigary29 September 2023
COGNITIVE DISSONANCE is NOT something the show's producers should have fostered, as they most certainly and unfortunately did here--IN SPADES!

Here a corrupt Matt merely rebukes McCready, his son and his henchman Bart when they are discovered by Matt trespassing and feloniously breaking and entering for the purpose of and caught in the act of committing arson to the Gabriel home. And what is more, the McCready son went unpunished when he slashed the Gabriel horse bridle with the intention of causing their carriage to careen out of control. This was to allow the criminal McCready and his two accomplices time to torch the Gabriel house and flee the premises undetected. Matt directly witnessed yet turned a blind eye to all of this! SHAME!!!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An unsatisfying entry
jdeamara13 September 2023
This is the first aired episode with a "Produced by Norman Macdonnell" credit. Beginning with episode 27, "Cooter," Macdonnell had been credited as associate producer under Charles Marquis Warren. With his end credit missing, it looks like Warren is no longer associated with the program.

The John Smith in this show can't be the John Smith from Laramie. Laramie's John Smith was born in 1931; he'd have been 25 in 1956. The John Smith here is a skinny 15 year old kid, like the other boy in this episode.

This show really doesn't properly address a woman deliberately giving a boy a deadly disease. I don't think Matt Dillon would really be ok with that. Also how the woman gave the boy the disease is really contrived. Days earlier the boy was in her house threatening to burn her house down; would the boy really come by days later and ask for a drink of water?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed