(TV Series)

(1981)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Important.
planktonrules18 May 2013
Throughout the last several decades, a variety of insanely dangerous weight loss programs have come and gone. In some cases, they left because they didn't work. In others, they might have worked but had a minor side effect...DEATH! For example, in the 1960s and 70s, amphetamines were prescribed to help folks drop the pounds--and turned them into junkie or gave them heart attacks. The Liquid Protein diet and Fen Phen were associated with more deaths. And, a few of the weight loss books recommended eliminating entire food groups or doing goofy things to make the pounds supposedly, disappear. Because of all these nutty attempts to lose weight, the folks at "Quincy" decided to weigh-in on the issue.

The show begins with a model being photographed. However, she is out of it--and eventually she passes out and dies! The autopsy shows that the young lady PROBABLY died from a strange diet which dangerously dehydrated the lady--and, as usual, Quincy is mad! Coincidentally, Quincy is asked to appear on a talk show and talk about properly selecting a plastic surgeon (a follow up to an earlier episode involving doctors practicing outside their training and mutilating folks in the process)...along with the bozo who wrote the same diet book that killed the model. Not surprisingly, despite Asten's advice to hold his tongue, Quincy accuses this author of killing the model and all heck breaks loose. Will the department get sued for a bazillion dollars or will Quincy be able to back up his claims?

While this is a social issue episode, fortunately it's not as preachy as many. And, it is interesting and well made. Well worth seeing...and unfortunately, crazy diets STILL are with us and probably will be for a long time to come.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"This meal is so low calorie you'll be hungry before you've finished it." A crime free Quincy.
poolandrews23 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Sugar and Spice starts as fashion model Gretchen Stone (Lori Street) collapses & dies of a heart attack under the hot lights during a shoot, L.A. coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) is on the case but can find no logical reason why Gretchen would suddenly die of a heart attack. Upon talking with Gretchen's sister Penny (Lisa Jane Persky) Quincy discovers Gretchen was on a new sort of diet & he becomes convinced that the diet along with drugs she was using caused Gretchen's heart attack. By a strange coincidence Quincy is scheduled to appear on a TV talk show to discuss the safety of plastic surgery but Corinne O'Connor (Kathleen Nolan) the inventor of the diet which killed Gretchen is also due to appear on the show & when they both meet they argue & Quincy accuses her diet of being a killer on national TV which gets him into lots of trouble...

Episode 17 from season 6 this Quincy story was directed Georg Fenady & is one of those Quincy stories which has a central moral issue which revolves a tragedy that Quincy is investigating, in fact there is no crime element in Sugar and Spice at all but don't let that put you off. From a personal point of view even though I love the series I don't normally like these episodes which focus almost entirely on a social or moral issues as I prefer a good murder mystery but I thought this one was pretty good, it's not overly subtle & it's a touch predictable but it gets it's worthwhile message about dieting across effectively enough & the fact that the show does tackle these issues & can vary from murder mysteries to something completely different yet still retain it's entertainment value is one of the reasons why I like Quincy so much. Then there's the fact you get to see Quincy act like a bull in a china shop which is always great fun as Klugman does such a fantastic job of playing him & he gets to make his obligatory passionate speech of which there's at least a couple here.

There's a guy in this who plays a photographer & he must have one of the worst ginger handlebar moustaches I've ever seen! This episode keeps moving at a decent pace, it has some nice humour & Dr. Asten gets a slightly bigger role than normal. The guest cast do OK here, there is no crime in this one so neither Lt. Monahan & Sgt Brill feature until the closing 'feel good' scene at Danny's at the end.

Sugar and Spice is yet another top Quincy episode, I love the series & I could watch Klugman all day long so maybe I'm biased but what the hell I reckon this show is definitely worth watching.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Significant topic in a flawed episode
rayoflite2428 November 2015
Sugar and Spice begins with a young model collapsing and dying of a heart attack during a photo shoot. Quincy (Jack Klugman) conducts the autopsy and has difficulty pinpointing how exactly this happened in a healthy young woman, but through further investigation he learns that she was on a fad diet which significantly reduces fluid intake. Quincy is convinced that this along with her taking a prescription for an amphetamine meant to bolster her energy was the cause which puts him at odds with the creator of the diet, Corrine O'Connor (Kathleen Nolan). During a joint talk show appearance, Quincy accuses Corrine of causing the death of the model and also endangering the life of others on the diet which places him and the office of the medical examiner in a precarious legal situation.

While this episode does a good job of addressing the problems associated with fad diets and the potentially dangerous consequences if they are not balanced with proper nutrition, I found parts of it to be so far-fetched and flawed that it really brought it down from a quality standpoint. First off, Quincy identifies the diet as being the cause of death and then low and behold, he and the creator of the diet are coincidentally scheduled to be on the same talk show together! How convenient to set up the legal conflict and what were the odds of this happening accidentally?? It also didn't make sense to me that Quincy was on to discuss plastic surgery, when exactly did he become a plastic surgeon??

I also thought Quincy's defamation of the diet creator on the talk show was so over the top and ridiculous. While we all know he can fly off the handle sometimes and put his foot in his mouth, this was out there even for him especially after he was coached by Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) before the appearance not to say anything inflammatory. While Quincy can be temperamental sometimes, he is still a very intelligent man and I wasn't buying that he would subject himself to a multi-million dollar lawsuit and potentially losing his job in such a stupid manner.

On the positive side, this episode does address an important topic, but since the death was accidental there is no crime whatsoever and it becomes a campaign to prevent further negligence and misinformation that will cause harm to others on the diet. If you enjoy these types of episodes then you will appreciate this one, but there were just too many flawed aspects to make it a good one for me.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Entertaining but flawed
ApeLieUproar18 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I happened to catch the latter half of this episode on Cozi and a few things stuck out for me.

1) Quincy can't prove a certain weight-loss diet proves a girl's death. He's a medical examiner. How can he not possess a shred of proof? What did he find in the deceased body if not proof? Isn't that the job of a M.E.? To find and document proof? What does medical examination of cadavers entail if not finding clues?

2) How much proof do you need to show that taking amphetamines (surely by then to be proved to be habit-forming) and not drinking water is bad for you? Aren't these two things proof enough? The dehydration angle alone should constitute sufficient proof that a thing is bad for you. Not drinking water alone is hugely dangerous even before you enter amphetamines into the equation. It's fairly absurd.

Both of these things point to a rather contrived conflict and kind of mars the whole episode, which addresses a very important issue.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Huge coop-out
dspear-624-49876625 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy is about to have to admit he was wrong about saying the diet is dangerous. He accused them without having any proof, just his opinion being stated as fact. This is bordering on criminal on his part. And he is severely endangering the entire corners office's reputation

The show is missing the real issue which is that freedom requires responsibility. Austin is totally right that to prevent publication of the diet would abridge our freedom of speech. Before doing that, there must be PROOF of danger or falsehood. Lacking this proof, it is the responsibility of the readers to determine the value of the diet. This is the cost of freedom of speech.

Indeed, Quincy used the same freedom of speech he is trying to censor. He says he knows the diet caused the death. The diet publisher has to go to court to PROVE that Quincy did not really know, and so was liable for his false statement that he definitely knew. But Quincy can never be wrong. So he is miraculously saved when the sister collapses from the diet. What a terrible coop-out to save the hero
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed