"UFO" Kill Straker! (TV Episode 1970) Poster

(TV Series)

(1970)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
it could have been better.
planktonrules7 May 2010
Colonel Foster and a 'red shirt' are on a mission. Oddly, however, the Moon base loses radio contact with them for 16 hours. But, fortunately, they do arrive safely. In the intervening time, something odd happened to the two men, as they both are insanely angry at Commander Straker. The red shirt tries to even blow up the base just to kill Straker. As for Foster, he's bent on ruining Straker's reputation and getting him fired. When that doesn't work, he's willing to settle for shooting Straker instead. It doesn't take ESP to assume that somehow they were abducted and forced to do the aliens' bidding.

Despite sounding like a mega-super-cool idea for an episode, it wasn't great. Most of the reason I wasn't thrilled was that it was obvious early on that the two men had been altered somehow--yet it took the SHADO folks an amazing amount of time to realize this! Even when Straker's friend, Foster, began acting very, very abnormal, no one seemed to put two and two together to realize that aliens had kidnapped the men during the missing 16 hours. Duh. Had the indoctrination been more subtle and their behaviors more believable it would have been a better episode all around--as the basic story idea is cool. As is, it's only mildly interesting, but I must admit that the gun scene at the end is pretty exciting.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Squandered Again
simon_fay29 March 2013
Once more the writers and producers make sure logic and tension don't get too much in the way of an excellent premise. Seems they didn't even bother to reconcile the events depicted in the first few minutes with the characters' explanatory account later on in the show, an account glaringly at odds with the events.

The re-entry/brainwashing sequence is something else though - one of the series' highlights for me, excellent British post-psychedelic TV (see also 'Reflections in the Water' and 'Mindbender').

If the film reboot ever takes off I hope it draws on the side of the series that foregrounded such strangeness, along with the conspiratorial back-story and nocturnal goings-on in forested areas.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A bad idea for an episode
lor_22 August 2023
The series goes off on a misguided tangent with this episode, which introduces the notion of the UFO aliens able to take over and control the minds of humans, specifically a couple members of Ed's SHADO team. That gimmick destroys most of the series' point and logic -since with that ability the aliens should be able to very easily conquer Earth and in the short-term render SHADO as useless.

Billington is one of the men taken over and gets to act strangely and out of character for the duration of one episode. If this series had taken the modern mode of developing a continuous story line and history, progressing week after week, this particular segment simply wouldn't fit as part of the overall show.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed