Leslie's plan to get more people in the store works so well it brings in two robbers. It turns out to be Jim and Zack, two Super Value employees who hold everyone hostage. Ingrid gets Stockholm Syndrome and turns on her co-workers.
Discovering that Buck spent the night with his longtime crush, Amy Anderson, has left Leslie feeling old -- and he's determined to do something about it.
Todd wins some cattle playing cards, and Leslie has an idea to butcher them right in the store; the plan draws them closer together. Buck encourages Richard to be more macho as he auditions against Francis in an ice skating show.