The Real George Washington (TV Movie 2008) Poster

(2008 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Fair and Balanced Coverage
lavatch19 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This concise biographical profile of George Washington is not intended to have viewers stand up and cheer at the end. But it also does not seek to besmirch the character of Washington and promote the tearing down of statues. The filmmakers effectively portrayed Washington as an ambitious and flawed Founding Father. In the film, the layers are peeled away on various myths and preconceptions.

First, it was made clear that Washington's roots were not in the planter aristocracy of eighteenth-century America. He came from the middle echelon of the gentry class and was highly motivated to move up in society. It is stated in the film that "his modesty covered his ambition." That ambition drove him to become both wealthy and famous by 1776.

At age 20, Washington joined the Freemasons, hoping to establish influential contacts. He also married "up" in his contractual arrangement with Martha Custis, which brought him enormous tracks of land. The love his life may have been Sally Fairfax, a married woman who rejected his overt advances. But over time, he clearly became devoted to Martha.

The film also deflates the myth of Washington as a truth-teller, as set forth in the tall tale of the cherry tree that was retailed by Parson Weems. During the Revolutionary War, Washington engaged in the dark arts of spycraft, becoming a master of deception starting at Morristown. His ability to dupe the British into believing that his ragtag arm was much larger should not go unnoticed. His skills in intelligence helped to compensate for his substandard battlefield strategic abilities when compared with the British generals. His Culper Spy Ring in New York produced major results.

While the film did not cover Washington's two terms in office, which reveals a wiser and more astute leader, it nonetheless offers and incisive glimpse into the character of an American hero.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
The life of George Washington
jsgoodrich7 May 2010
This portrayal of Washington paints him as being ambitious to the point of extreme arrogance . The story goes out of its way to attribute horrible motives to Washington while presenting noteworthy or noble deeds as accomplishments of others or written off merely as luck. There is no historical context comparing the man with the times. There are very few of Washington's own words included, and when they are his intent is either distorted or the viewer is encouraged not to believe the validity. I ask how can a biography of Washington hope to be taken seriously when the crossing the Delaware is relegated to a few sentences?
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tucker Bowen's Distortion of Washington's Personality
jm502327 July 2010
Tucker Bowen's _Real George Washington_ digs in the graveyard of history to uncover evidence to support the presuppositions of Twentieth-Century liberal intellectualism. Bowen presents a picture of Washington that appears to be sketched by draft dodgers who sat on the sidelines during the Vietnam War and viewed the expansion of Classical Athens through the lenses of English bourgeois social reform and Marxist-Leninism. The result is a distortion of Washington's personality.

To gain a more accurate and balanced perception of a boy who lost his earthly father at the age of ten and grew up to become America's most indispensable man, the student of history should read _The Real George Washington_: part I: George Washington: The Man Who United America and part II: Timeless Treasures from George Washington published in Volume 3 of the American Classic Series by the National Center for Constitutional Studies in 2008. Jay A. Parry and Andrew M. Allison present a chronological narrative of Washington's activities from childhood through the French and Indian War, his two retirements and his death. With W. Cleon Skousen, they present selected quotes from Washington's writings in Part II. The full flavor of Washington's written record can be found in _George Washington's Sacred Fire_ by Peter A. Lillback (2006). These authors unveil the great dramatic actions of America's First President and the role he played in the Great American Symphony that produced the harmonious music of the American Federal Republic.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed