User Reviews

The animation was a joy to behold in this, but the experience kept getting put off by the messy story. Putting aside the insane lore-breaking in this...the story of the twins themselves seemed really rushed and out of focus. I think they had an interesting idea but the short runtime hurt the narrative a lot in this one.

Not sure how I felt about this episode, currently watching all the episodes in order and this one especially one left me with mixed feelings. I felt like the story took a big hit due to lack of time, which isn't the Japanese studios fault, I get what they were trying to do with this episode and on paper this could've been one of the better episodes. The concept is great, a pair of twins, one good, one evil, the only problem I had was the direction the story took. First of all, breathing in space? Really? Come on now I get that these episodes aren't canon but it was extremely distracting to me during the big fight scene. I did like the evil twin, her lightsaber whips were awesome, but the good twin didn't make any sense to me. How are they both born, raised and conditioned together to be both evil Sith Lords and the brother is just randomly a good guy? After all these years he was just holding it in? I get that he was doing it just to save his sister but that's not something a sith would do. I have to keep reminding myself that these aren't canon. I hope we get to see them again because I feel like it could develop into a great story with even better characters. And that ending scene!!! Seeing a star destroyer getting sliced into 2 by a lightsaber was just beautiful!!! Literally. I want to print out that shot and hang it on a wall. Shout out to the artists that worked on this episode.

Flashy but very irealistic fights. The story didn't make me feel anything. The characters were okay, but that's pretty much it.

Since when can people breathe in space and move freely? Since when do savers bend like strings?

This episode felt so much like Star Wars. I think the other reviews are trying to take these episodes too literally. They meant to be over the top and exceed the "rules". That's pretty typical for anime. This story is the heart of Star Wars. The duality of man, having the right to a choice, impossible odds, families at odds with each other.

Beautiful animation and art, awesome fighting choreography or whatever you want to call what that crazy stuff was, boy sibling trying to get through to his sister was touching, homage to Luke & Leia. It's like an alternate universe version of what their life could've been if the Sith got them at birth.

When the guy twin cut that Star Destroyer in half my jaw was on the floor. Insane, but I loved it. The girl twin is one of the best anime girls of 2021.

I'm fine with them breathing in space because they were artificially created so that could've been factored into their creation. They're also both so powerful with the force in my head cannon they're just using the force like a Black Clover mana skin or ten from HxH or a Lantern power ring outline

So many cool moments I want more of this story.

Preachy kid tries to murder his sister in order to save her life.

Doesn't really make much sense, more of a mishmash of overused anime tropes thrown into a blender with a little Star Wars nail polish.

I mean, I thought it was pretty decent. I must not be much of a screenwriter because I didn't seem to dislike this short story as much as everyone else. Isn't that sort of the point of a short story? To have something that's at least investing enough if it isn't strong? You can only do so much with this time frame I feel. Perhaps this would have been better at an hour long.

I think the first half feels like star wars and the last half less so with all of the breathing in space and weird lightsabers and some other logic that didn't quite make sense. But I do agree with anyone saying it's not technically "canon", so I don't know, I guess physics and stuff don't work the same here as they do in the other movies and shows.

The animation is truly stunning, as was the voice work. I will admit that the references got a little silly. I'd feel a little guilty being a jerk about it though. This is someone else's "vision" and I hope they're happy about it. I'm content enough and just happy this kind of Star Wars show exists.

This episode was kinda dull. The action was a little cool, but quickly became unbelievable when Karre and Am were in zero grav, but also not, and not suffocating. Why couldn't the battle have taken place just above a planet surface?

Somehow it is amazing that more stupidity has been condensed here for a quarter of an hour than TLJ has for two and a half hours. Super cyber-crystal! Lightsaber beam! Light-whiplashes! Ad hoc lightsaber coming out of a sith power suit! Twin star destroyer! Breathing in space! Hyperspace jumping into a star destroyer and cutting it in half with a rainbow-lightsaber while precisely destroying an inch long crystal on the chest of a sith gal! Surviving a hyperspace jump without a spacesuit standing on top of a trashed X-wing! (It's a nice attempt to legitimize the Holdo maneuver, but it's still absurd rubbish, but at least you've managed to cover it up with a bigger absurdity, the Karre maneuver! Give us a break guys, just one year without impossible, rule breaking shenanigans, one year! Is it too much to ask?!)

Honestly, it's art to squeeze so many damn nonsense idiotism into a quarter of an hour! When you mutter to yourself every 10-15 seconds in shocked disbelief -What the world am I looking at?!, you know you're eating quality Star Wars compost manure again! And the dialogues! Oh those dialogues! I don't know who wrote them, but I'm also sure they hasn't really met a living person yet, and has been trying to tutor themself from the big sausage pizza-type adult movies. Don't be shy now, keep winking at Star Wars with blatant references because that's very important, as we know! An "I have a bad feeling about this..." a day keeps the angry fans away, right?! But hey, at least the graphic style is kinda good! It looks cool, and cool things are happening! Wow, so animu, very 'sterwers! I would applaud, but somehow I still have standards.

Everything about this episode is terrible. Almost everything that happens it lore breaking and is plain disrespectful to everything Star Wars. The "super lightsabre" thing is stupid, the fight in the vacuum of space is stupid and the jump to hyperspace with Karre on the outside of the ship is stupid. The dialogue is terrible with very forced cliche Star Wars lines. I know that the purpose of visions is to push the boundaries of what Star Wars is and episodes like "the ninth Jedi" do that spectacularly, but this episode is just stupid.