User Reviews

But I also felt like the writers copied to much from the Original Charmed when Prue left. So a lot of the emotion I was feeling with the episode felt recycled and a cheap. I'm gonna miss Macy though. Curious where it goes from here.

The new Charmed is finally becoming good and I like it very much, but copying the end of the Charmed ones?

It's almost exactly copying the og Charmed, it even happened at the end of season 3 like in the original one.

As far as I know the same producer did both shows, did they forget, that they had to made this storyline in the og Charmed because Shannen Doherty left? Did Madeleine Mantock have to go, too? I hope the next "Sister" will be a better actress than Rose McGowan in the og Charmed.

Yes we can compare to OG Charmed. But apart from a main actress leaving after the 3td season and finding out there is another Charmed one out there, that is where this comparison ends.

At least Madeleine gave a proper time notice for her departure; which made this season finale a proper one because the writers came up with a storyline tat make sense. Also she could always come back like the producers said.

Finding out there is another sister (or maybe a guy, who knows!) is the way the OG Power was reconstituted but it might not happen the same way, I hope so.

Very emotional episode, well acted. Kudos to Madeleine. Her acting was touching.

It is clear season 3 exhausted the series chances at being aggressively woke. And is practically free of it at one point. There are still those annoying characters like Jordan, but maybe next season will give him interesting things to do. Instead of just suffering through the consequences of knowing the charmed ones. I was fine with him leaving, but writers decided otherwise. I never was on board with the Harry/Macy love story, either. But it don't matter anymore, now that she's gone. I'm still not sold on this new version of Charmed, and probably will never be. But this season finale got the job done. It was full of special moments and shocking revelations, and made me look forward to the finale season. They could've done without the flashback montage, before Macy's « rise ». It was very bad and unnecessary. Or pick a different song for it.