User Reviews

This episode is so painful to watch, especially for parents. Your son wandering the streets, while you're panicking, searching for him everywhere is every parent worst nightmare, especially if he/she is visually impaired.

I would love people to appreciate three persons in this episode: 1) baby Jack, for being absolutely the best kid actor I've seen so far. I just wanted him to be protected at all costs :( 2) Rebecca, for being the anchor of it all and saving the situation, even though she's suffering from memory loss every now and then and felt that she'd be useless to her kids. She just ran there, like the superhero she is, and save Jack. I love love love this moment. Just to prove that both Rebecca and Mandy Moore deserves all the love in the whole world, and I will protest if they didn't give her an Emmy.

3) our precious Beth for being the most unbothered and funny character in this show. I love her!!

P. S. I am not taking sides in this Katoby fiasco, because, in all honesty, I can understand both their situation, which reflects the brilliance of this show.

I'm completely with Toby on this one, who in their right mind shows a toddler ANY toddler how to open the front door?! Yes he owned up to not hearing the gate close to little Jacks room, he took responsibility for it! Little Jack is just the cutest little boy ever! Grandma Rebecca coming to the rescue and realising exactly where Jack had gone! Totally heartbreaking when he said the park was the only place his mum and dad were happy together and seeing the world through his eyes!

I feel so bad for Toby, he's trying! And Kate is so ughhhh! And Kevin constantly coming to her defense...WHEN SHE'S WRONG! It's nice that he defends her as a brother should do but when the person is wrong...it's not cool and quite unfair. I'm not sure what will happen between Toby and Kate but I think I have an idea based on the last episode of Season 5, when the English guy that Kate works with called Kevin brother in law. And there was another episode in either Season 3 or 4 where they fast forwarded to the future, and everyone met up at the house Kevin was going to build for Rebecca, and Rebecca was in bed, fully old and with complete dementia, and in one scene Toby was in his bed looking depressed before he went to go join everyone at the house. This made me think they may not stay together. I hope that in the very end, even if Kate and Toby don't end up together that the writers create some kind of happy ending for Toby. Maybe he went to a bar to have a few drinks while being very sad and happen to meet a very pretty stranger and they get to talking. Idk SOMETHING!! Don't leave Toby hanging.

I wasn't sure how to rate this episode as the dynamics between Kate and Toby are both painful to watch and also portrayed so realistically. But what effected me most was seeing the hardships through little Jack's point of view. As a mother to a little one about his age, it absolutely tore my heart up to find out Little Jack went to the park because that was the only place both his parents were happy together. I'm still having a hard time not crying. I don't want to go on a big rant here, but I'm hoping the writers have a plan for Katoby, because they were one of my favorite couples in the beginning and watching their marriage crash and burn doesn't give me much hope. Also, I am over seeing Toby made out as a villain and Kate the victim. Again, painful to watch, but well acted and very REAL feeling.

...You guessed it, Kate.. Why do the writers of this show feel like they Have to make her character so weak and pathetic?

The episode itself were great, and i would rate it a 9 if it weren't for Kate.

The writing itself is also weak, like when she and Toby had the big fight outside their home. She act as if the gate to Jacks room MUST be closed but then she argued with Toby that Jack MUST learn to be independent RIGHT NOW. Toby actually owns up to his mistake EVERY single time, and even if Kate makes more mistakes than Toby she NEVER owns up to them. She only want to be the victim in every scenario.

The writers need to either do better at their writing, Or they need to write Kate out of the whole show because this is just sad..