"Anne with an E" Signs Are Small Measurable Things, But Interpretations Are Illimitable (TV Episode 2018) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Trinidadians don't talk so
angelicsk20019 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
In this episode, when Bash and Gilbert dock in Trinidad, as a born and raised Trinidadian I could appreciate the accuracy of the dishes, what ingredients they consist of and how the dishes are made like crab and callalloo. I could even appreciate the descriptive language that are used like "skylarkin", "magga", "bush medicine", "dregs", "dou dou", and many more. However, what really troubled me about this episode and quite possibly maybe the episodes to follow is.....Bash's 'Trini accent'.

Given that a Trinidadian's accent is so distinctive and it is usually commented on just as much as the food and lifestyle as well as it can be heard via so many mediums, I held a high expectation for this character to feel like I was really watching a Trinidadian bredren.

While clear research was done to represent the food and life in Trinidad as accurately as possible in this episode, the actor playing Bash was no way near accurately portraying a Trini accent at all. In fact, he sounded more Jamaican than anything else. Maybe he was trying to get a handle on the 'sing songy' way that foreigners often describe Trinis' speech but to me, his portrayal was no where close. Really and truly it bothered me so much when he spoke I felt like I was hearing intermittent screeches of chalk on a black board.

What upset me as well is that the writer iiiissss a Trinidadian (hence all the Trinidadian symbolisms throughout) thereby the person could have been consulted for pointers on how to speak Trini. Had the Trini accent been accurately done, tied together with the phrases and the almost perfect atmosphere, I could have enjoyed the character much more. Right now he feels kinda fakeish.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Why not create your own show
jimmietee6 January 2023
If you don't care to tell the story of Anne of Green Gables then why tie your horse to that hitching post. So everything in this story is made up. As in not in the book. But then they twist things for the period. Trinidad got rid of slavery 50 years prior to Bash and Gilbert walking around for some reason the guy with the horse assume Bash is the first slave in decades to show up. But really he only called him boy not slave. So really why did they not assume he was talking to Gilbert who was the one actually messing around with the horse? Forced perspective is bad writing.

And then they visit mom who says you can't visit. And the admit slavery ended 50 year prior but they don't speak to why he can't visit his free mother.

So yeah, they went from a story written in the period to a modern story dressed up in old clothing.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed