Punch-Drunk Love | 10/10
After a few viewings over the course of five years, I've come to realize that this is one of the most unique films I've ever seen. Surely that alone does not make it a good film, but I think it's worth mentioning because of how well it works. The synopsis of the film is utterly ridiculous, Adam Sandler is the most incomprehensible choice for something with any artistic value whatsoever, and the overall look of most scenes could quite easily annoy a person to no end. Luckily for me, I see no problem with any of this. Within the realm of what actually happens in this picture, the plot is necessary, Sandler is perfect, and the cinematography is astonishing. These things alone only touch the surface of what's presented over the course of an hour and a half.
Director Paul Thomas Anderson already had a couple of great films behind him before he decided on this project. These films, however, were ensemble pieces and very much epic in scale. He proves here that he can be just as (if not more) effective with a few strong characters and a toned-down yet equally interesting vision. Sandler's Barry Egan is quiet, reserved, lonely, and clearly depressed with his seemingly empty life. He is a -real- character that some of us may have known at least once in our lives, and more importantly, one that even more of us can relate to whether we'd like to admit it or not. Anderson surrounds his character with various clues, both visual and spoken, that show us who he is, the person he would like to be, and what he may need in his life to achieve such things. Thus we're presented with one of the great actresses working today, Emily Watson. After an early morning car crash and an equally random (or not) appearance of a Harmonium, Watson's Lena walks into Barry's life. She, to a certain extent, is also reserved, and almost seems a bit too perfect to be real, or at least from around here ("People are just crazy in this world, I think."). That line, as dormant as it sounds, speaks a great deal to me about her character and the possibilities that exist within it. She says this after Barry is attacked by the brothers of Mattress Man, the bogus phone-sex company that Barry calls during a routine moment of lonely desperation.
As cliché as it may sound, I really do think that the basic motive for this film's existence is a desire to show the power of love and acceptance. Where it succeeds is it's flawless presentation. At the beginning of this film, Barry doesn't like the person that he is and really sees no reason for even trying to meet someone new. He is almost content with his small business and obsessive discovery of a marketing mistake that no normal person would even have the desire to uncover. As we see him playing his once silent and broken Harmonium, it's connection with his own heart and soul becomes clear.
Regardless of how much you like this film, or if you like it at all, it is not one that can be turned off and forgotten immediately. In fact for those that are willing, there are quite a few layers that become apparent only through multiple viewings. For instance, pay attention to the appearance of a lady in red during Barry's first trip to the supermarket, and how during many scenes we're given an otherworldly visual description of what would seem to be otherwise normal environments. If you're not interested in such things, then I'd still suggest watching this for entertainment purposes alone. As much as I find myself complaining about mainstream cinema, I almost take comfort in knowing that I'll eventually come across something this perfect in a sea of uninspired mediocrity.
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends