If she loved Jessie, she should have returned to him when she found out he was still alive. She may have learned to live without him for several years and felt affection for her best friend, Sam, who had been there for her during her grief, but real love is supposed to be embedded in one's heart despite anything that happens. She may have been able to move on with her life, accepting tragedy, but it's hardly believable that she could choose another man over her one true and first love. In the real world, it's improbable she would choose Sam over Jessie because Sam is only a replacement for a lost soulmate. Therefore, the conclusion is that she wasn't in love with Jesse, as she chose Sam in the end. Also, it would have been more natural if Luke Bracey had his Australian accent in the movie. His American accent here is quite unnatural.
Review of One True Loves
